Go to the basement and get the key from the corpse.Use your Mind’s Eye on all the statues to reveal their true nature.The Redemption Church can be found in Salvation Harbor so travel there.Archives: Visit Oakmont’s University Library and select “History/17th-19th Century/Local.” You’ll get the address to the old church.Speak to Warren and he’ll tell you about an old church used for pagan worship.Mary’s Hospital in Coverside and use the following entries – “Patients/After the Flood/Surgery.” You’ll find Warren upstairs. You’re now looking for a certain James Warren who has a head injury.Retrocognition: (1) “Another one for you, burn him!” (2) “What by the Aingeals is going on?” (3) Next to the furnace with a person getting knocked out, (4) “I need to get out of here.”.Check all the evidence in the crematorium and morgue, especially the putrid slime.Check the desk at the morgue for a key to the crematorium itself.You’ll have the address to the Oakmont Crematorium in southern Reed Heights.Use your Mind’s Eye to follow the spectral tentacles and find the key. Speak to the taskmaster again and he’ll allow you to go upstairs.Kill the monsters and speak to the thief.Use your Mind’s Eye to follow the Omens/shadow crows to the nearby yard.Speak to the taskmaster who wants you to get a sack of potatoes from the basement.Travel to Carpenter Manor (just north of Throgmorton’s mansion).Carpenter tells you that he was placed inside a crematorium’s furnace and, when he escaped, he found out that someone was wearing his face.
Head there and you’ll be escorted to meet Brutus Carpenter.